I like Pink Floyd, infact I consider them the best band to have ever walked the earth. They've written more than a few album that could be considered all time greats. One problem I do have with Pink Floyd is their output after 1985, after Roger Waters left. Why? The song writing went way down hill and they became your run of the mill rock and roller's who brought nothing new to the table. The album starts off decent enough, I can't really knock Signs of Life apart from the fact it's a bit of a waste of a track. The sound of water slowly lapping against the side of a boat with the hum of a synth over the top doesn't really constitute a song but i'll let it slide, after all this is David Gilmour and he knows what he's doing. Next up is Learning to Fly, your first introduction to the new, radio friendly Pink Floyd. I can't really knock this either fortunately; for a Prog Rock band Pink Floyd have done a very good job at creating an actual single. Things suddenly take a turn for the worse.
The Dogs of War kick starts this album on a sharp decline. David Gilmour suddenly decides he's Roger Waters and over some pretty suspect saxaphone playing goes on a rant about something or other. One Slip is an average, plodding, stadium rock tune which was helpfully contributed by Phil Manzanera of Roxy Musix fame. Things pick up slightly with On The Turning Away, the stand out track. Yes, this is the Pink Floyd we used to know, a touching acoustic ditty with coherent lyrics. By the end of this song you're willing to give them the benefit of the doubt, okay there were a few suspect tunes but maybe things will get better from here on in.
I'm going to spoil it for you and just say no, no they don't. Yet Another Movie/Round and Around are fucking woeful. There is no other term for it. Surely it can't get any worse. Oh it can, A New Machine is split into two parts, bookending the equally dire Terminal Frost and is just David Gilmour talking into a voice box. It is quite simply a waste of recording time and money and should leave anyone who bought this record feeling short change. The formentioned Terminal Frost is an instrumental in which more saxaphone is shoved down our throats while being broken up by some fairly choppy fret wanking from Mr. Gilmour.
Sorrow, the very last song starts off with a distorted guitar solo from Gilmour, getting your hopes in the process and then develops into another plodding attempt at a stadium anthem. Even Dave seems to be getting tired by this point and his droning vocals just don't capture the imagination one bit.
Is this a genuinely bad album or is it just a massive dissapointment? Well, i've thought long and hard about it and it has got to be the former. This isn't Pink Floyd we're listening to, it's a tribute act. They've got the cover art, they've got the album name and they even show glimpses of being the real deal but they haven't got what they most needed, Roger Waters. A Momentary Lapse of Reason? More like a momentary lapse of talent.






